Addressing Inspection Risk in TWO COOL® Assembly & Packaging Template

Since product or process yield depends on the accuracy of metrology and inspection, we must consider the costs of discarding a good device and the cost of accepting a bad device. Measurement risk is illustrated in Table I. Minimizing the cost of shipping a bad device is one purpose of metrology and inspection. However, if the sampling plan or methods are insufficient, bad devices will be shipped. But if specifications are too restrictive, then good devices may be rejected.

Measurement Risk

True State
Measured Result
Error
Good
Good
None
Bad
Bad
None
Good
Bad
Type I (alpha)
Bad
Good
Type II (beta)

The probabilities of discarding a good device and of shipping a bad device are related to the variance of the measurement. These probabilities may be reduced by reducing variance, increasing sample size, or developing more robust processes.

TWO COOL®'s assembly and packaging template has two inputs for yield, Equipment Yield and Parametric Limited Yield Loss. Yield is the product of all of the independent yield mechanisms. Since alpha risk and beta risk are often described in terms of probabilities, we convert the probabilities of risk loss into alpha and beta yields. Then, since TWO COOL® has a formula builder, we can replace the equipment yield input with a formula that considers equipment yield, alpha risk and beta risk. Input the following formula into the Equipment Yield input cell:

Equation 1

=E*(1-A)*(1-B)

where:

E = Equipment Yield in decimal form (i.e. 0.999)

A = risk probability (i.e. 0.001)

B = risk (i.e. 0.0001)

Equation 1 includes all yield factors in the cost of scrap calculation for Assembly and Packaging cost of ownership. Using Equation 1 has one error however. Normally the cost of shipping bad product is much greater than the cost of rejecting good product. Equation 1 treats these costs equally. If both costs of measurement risk can be estimated then Equation 1 can be modified to reflect the difference in the costs of alpha risk and beta risk:

Equation 2

=E*(1-A)*(1-(B*S/R))

where:

E = Equipment Yield in decimal form (i.e. 0.999)

A = Alpha risk probability (i.e. 0.001)

B = Beta risk (i.e. 0.0001)

S = Cost of shipping a bad product (i.e. \$100.00)

R = Cost of rejecting a good product (i.e. \$10.00)

Normally R is equal to the Value of Incoming Unit at this Point in Process found in the administrative rates section of TWO COOL®.

Back to Top

SITE MAP 1SITE MAP 2SITE MAP3

6200 Stoneridge Mall Road • 3rd Floor • Pleasanton, CA 94588 • Tel 925-399-6246 • Fax 925-396-6174
©1995-2015 Wright Williams & Kelly, Inc. • All Rights Reserved • Email: [email protected]